If you’ve never tried buffalo before, your mind should pretty well be made up when ordering here—slow-roasted buffalo dishes are the house specialty. If you have already made your culinary acquaintance with buffalo, then your decision will most likely be quite a bit more difficult, as you’ll be faced with old favorites like London broil, crab cakes, and chicken potpie. True to its name, the Stagecoach Inn has a Western theme. The rustic log structure (built in 1881) resembles a barn, and an old-fashioned stagecoach greets customers as they enter.

Stage Coach Inn Information:

• American menu. Lunch, dinner. Closed Jan 1, Dec 25. Bar. Children's menu. Casual attire. Reservations recommended (summer). Outdoor seating. Credit cards accepted.